SGU Ratings on imdb

[Red Mage]

I wanted to try this for SGA for myself to cross check (SG1 is too much trouble going over 10 seasons, but maybe later...):

Season 1: A
Season 2: B-
Season 3: B+
Season 4: A-
Season 5: B

So my rating for SGA would be: (4 + 2.7 + 3.3 + 3.7 + 3)/5 * 2.5 = 8.4 (B+)//

I'll give SGA a go myself...

Season One

Rising: A (4.0)
Rising Pt 2: A (4.0)
Hide and Seek: B+ (3.3)
Thirty Eight Minutes: A (4.0)
Suspicion: C (2.0)
Childhood's End: C (2.0)
Poisoning the Well: B+ (3.3)
Underground: C+ (2.3)
Home: A- (3.7)
The Storm: C+ (2.3)
The Eye: A- (3.7)
The Defiant One: B+ (3.3)
Hot Zone: B (3.0)
Sanctuary: B (3.0)
Before I sleep: A- (3.7)
The Brotherhood: C (2.0)
Letters From Pegasus: A- (3.7)
The Gift: B (3.0)
The Siege Part 1: A (4.0)
The Seige Part 2: A (4.0)
-------------------------
B (3.21)

Season Two

The Seige Part 3: A (4.0)
The Intruder: B+ (3.3)
Runner: A (4.0)
Duet: A- (3.7)
Condemned: C (2.0)
Trinity: A- (3.7)
Instinct: B+ (3.3)
Conversion: B+ (3.3)
Aurora: A- (3.7)
The Lost Boys: B+ (3.3)
The Hive: B+ (3.3)
Epiphany: A- (3.7)
Critical Mass: B- (2.7)
Grace Under Pressure: A- (3.7)
The Tower: C+ (2.3)
The Long Goodbye: B- (2.7)
Coup D'etat: B (3.0)
Michael: B (3.0)
Inferno: B+ (3.3)
Allies: B (3.0)
-----------------------------
B (3.25)

Season Three

No Man's Land: C+ (2.3)
Misbegotten: C (2.0)
Irresistible: F (0)
Sateda: A- (3.7)
Progeny: B+ (3.3)
The Real World: A- (3.7)
Common Ground: B+ (3.3)
Mckay and Mrs. Miller: A- (3.7)
Phantoms: B (3.0)
The Return Part 1: A- (3.7)
The Return Part 2: A (4.0)
Echoes: B (3.0)
Irresponsible: F (0)
Tao of Rodney: A- (3.7)
The Game: B+ (3.3)
The Ark: D (1.0)
Sunday: A (4.0)
Submersion: B (3.0)
Vengeance: B- (2.7)
First Strike: A (4.0)
-----------------------
B- (2.88)

Season Four

Adrift: A (4.0)
Lifeline: A (4.0)
Reunion: B (3.0)
Doppleganger: B (3.0)
Travelers: B+ (3.3)
Tabula Rasa: A- (3.7)
Missing: D (1.0)
The Seer: C- (1.7)
Miller's Crossing: B+ (3.3)
This Mortal Coil: A- (3.7)
Be All My Sins Remember'd: A (4.0)
Spoils of War: B (3.0)
Quarantine: B (3.0)
Harmony: D (1.0)
Outcast: B+ (3.3)
Trio: D (1.0)
Midway: B+ (3.3)
The Kindred Part 1: B (3.0)
The Kindred Part 2: B+ (3.3)
The Last Man: A (4.0)
----------------------------
B (2.98) rounded up to (3.0)

Season Five

Search and Rescue: B (3.0)
The Seed: B (3.0)
Broke Ties: B (3.0)
The Daedalus Variations: A (4.0)
Ghost in the Machine: A- (3.7)
The Shrine: A- (3.7)
Whispers: C (2.0)
Tracker: B (3.0)
The Queen: B+ (3.3)
First Contact: B+ (3.3)
The Lost Tribe: B+ (3.3)
Inquisition: F (0)
Outsiders: C (2.0)
The Prodigal: C (2.0)
Remnants: C+ (2.3)
Brain Storm: D (1.0)
Infection: D (1.0)
Identity: C- (1.7)
Vegas: A (4.0)
Enemy at the Gate: C+ (2.3)
---------------------------
C+ (2.58)

Season 1: B (3.21)
Season 2: B (3.25)
Season 3: B- (2.88)
Season 4: B (2.98)
Season 5: C+ (2.58)
---------------------------
B (2.98) rounded up to (3.0)

A "B" is about right for SGA. I love SGA but the show tends to be inconsistant at times. Some episodes are really good and then there's the rather numerous "filler" episodes that drag down the series as whole when compiling the grades of each episode.

Thanks to Briangate for posting the episode list at:
http://forums.syfy.com/index.php?showtopic=2263302
That list made the process an easy copy and paste of the episodes in a word document which made my life easier.

 

[EvilSpaceAlien]

Here's how I'd rate SGA, but I'm too goddamn tired to do any math, plus I also take the season arc when I grade the entire seasons.

Season One:

1.01-1.02 Rising - A+
1.03 Hide and Seek - C+
1.04 Thirty Eight Minutes - A
1.05 Suspicion - C-
1.06 Childhood's End - C
1.07 Poisoning the Well - A-
1.08 Underground - A
1.09 Home - B+
1.10 The Storm - A+
1.11 The Eye - A+
1.12 The Defiant One - B+
1.13 Hot Zone - A
1.14 Sanctuary - B-
1.15 Before I Sleep - A+
1.16 The Brotherhood - C
1.17 Letters From Pegasus - A-
1.18 The Gift - B-
1.19 The Siege, Pt 1 - A+
1.20 The Siege, Pt 2 - A+

Season Two:

2.01 The Siege, Pt 3 - A
2.02 The Intruder - B-
2.03 Runner - A
2.04 Duet - A
2.05 Condemned - D
2.06 Trinity - B-
2.07 Instinct - C
2.08 Conversion - C-
2.09 Aurora - B+
2.10 The Lost Boys - B-
2.11 The Hive - C
2.12 Epiphany - C-
2.13 Critical Mass - C+
2.14 Grace Under Pressure - B+
2.15 The Tower - D-
2.16 The Long Goodbye - C-
2.17 Coup D'etat - C
2.18 Michael - B+
2.19 Inferno - C+
2.20 Allies - C+

Season Three:

3.01 No Man's Land - C-
3.02 Misbegotten - C-
3.03 Irresistible - F
3.04 Sateda - A+
3.05 Progeny - C
3.06 The Real World - A
3.07 Common Ground - B+
3.08 McKay and Mrs. Miller - B-
3.09 Phantoms - C-
3.10 The Return, Pt 1 - B
3.11 The Return, Pt 2 - B+
3.12 Echoes - C-
3.13 Irresponsible - F
3.14 Tao of Rodney - C+
3.15 The Game - C
3.16 The Ark - C-
3.17 Sunday - A+
3.18 Submersion - A-
3.19 Vengeance - C
3.20 First Strike - A+

Season Four:

4.01 Adrift - A-
4.02 Lifeline - A
4.03 Reunion - C
4.04 Doppleganger - C+
4.05 Travelers - D
4.06 Tabula Rasa - B+
4.07 Missing - D-
4.08 The Seer - C
4.09 Miller's Crossing - C+
4.10 This Mortal Coil - A-
4.11 Be All My Sins Remember'd - A-
4.12 Spoils of War - C+
4.13 Quarantine - C
4.14 Harmony - F
4.15 Outcast - B-
4.16 Trio - C+
4.17 Midway - A-
4.18 The Kindred, Pt 1 - B+
4.19 The Kindred, Pt 2 - C-
4.20 The Last Man - A+

Season Five:

5.01 Search and Rescue - B-
5.02 The Seed - B-
5.03 Broken Ties - D-
5.04 The Daedalus Variations - A+
5.05 Ghost in the Machine - F
5.06 The Shrine - B
5.07 Whispers - F
5.08 Tracker - D+
5.09 The Queen - C-
5.10 First Contact - B-
5.11 The Lost Tribe - C
5.12 Inquisition - F-
5.13 Outsiders - F
5.14 The Prodigal - D+
5.15 Remnants - B+
5.16 Brain Storm - F-
5.17 Infection - D-
5.18 Identity - F
5.19 Vegas - A+
5.20 Enemy at the Gate - F-

Season 1: A+
Season 2: C
Season 3: C-
Season 4: C+
Season 5: F
Entire series: C, watchable but not something I'd feel the need to follow regularly

 

[EvilSpaceAlien]

Here's SG1 and SGU, spoilertagged due to length.

SG1

Spoiler: -

Season One:
1.01-1.02 Children of the Gods - B
1.03 The Enemy Within - A-
1.04 Emancipation - D-
1.05 The Broca Divide - C+
1.06 The First Commandment - A
1.07 Brief Candle - C-
1.08 Cold Lazarus - D
1.09 Thor's Hammer - B+
1.10 The Torment of Tantalus - A
1.11 Bloodlines - C+
1.12 Fire and Water - F
1.13 The Nox - B
1.14 Hathor - F
1.15 Singularity - B+
1.16 Cor-ai - C-
1.17 Enigma - C+
1.18 Tin Man - C+
1.19 Solitudes - A-
1.20 There But for the Grace of God - A+
1.21 Politics - A-
1.22 Within the Serpent's Grasp - A

Season Two:
2.01 The Serpent's Lair - A
2.02 In the Line of Duty - A-
2.03 Prisoners - B
2.04 The Gamekeeper - B+
2.05 Need - C-
2.06 Thor's Chariot - B+
2.07 Message in a Bottle - A
2.08 Family - B-
2.09 Secrets - B+
2.10 Bane - B+
2.11 The Tok'ra, Pt 1 - A
2.12 The Tok're, Pt 2 - A+
2.13 Spirits - C-
2.14 Touchstone - A
2.15 The Fifth Race - A+
2.16 A Matter of Time - A
2.17 Holiday - D-
2.18 Serpent's Song - A
2.19 One False Step - F
2.20 Show and Tell - B+
2.21 1969 - A
2.22 Out of Mind - D-

Season Three:
3.01 Into the Fire - B-
3.02 Seth - B+
3.03 Fair Game - A
3.04 Legacy - D+
3.05 Learning Curve - D+
3.06 Point of View - A-
3.07 Deadman Switch - A-
3.08 Demons - B
3.09 Rules of Engagement - B+
3.10 Forever in a Day - B
3.11 Past and Present - B
3.12 Jolinar's Memories - A
3.13 The Devil You Know - A+
3.14 Foothold - A-
3.15 Pretense - A-
3.16 Urgo - B+
3.17 A Hundred Days - B+
3.18 Shades of Gray - A+
3.19 New Ground - A-
3.20 Maternal Instinct - A
3.21 Crystal Skull - A-
3.22 Nemesis - A

Season Four:
4.01 Small Victories - A+
4.02 The Other Side - A
4.03 Upgrades - A-
4.04 Crossroads - B
4.05 Divide and Conquer - A
4.06 Window of Opportunity - A+
4.07 Watergate - B-
4.08 The First Ones - B-
4.09 Scorched Earth - B+
4.10 Beneath the Surface - A
4.11 Point of No Return - A
4.12 Tangent - A-
4.13 The Curse - A
4.14 The Serpent's Venom - A
4.15 Chain Reaction - B+
4.16 2010 - A+
4.17 Absolute Power - A
4.18 The Light - D+
4.19 Prodigy - C
4.20 Entity - C-
4.21 Double Jeopardy - B
4.22 Exodus - A+

Season Five:
4.01 Enemies - A+
4.02 Threshold - A
4.03 Ascension - A
4.04 The Fifth Man - B+
4.05 Red Sky - A+
4.06 Rite of Passage - C+
4.07 Beast of Burden - C-
4.08 The Tomb - C
4.09 Between Two Fires - A+
4.10 2001 - A+
4.11 Desperate Measures - B+
4.12 Wormhole X-Treme! - A-
4.13 Proving Ground - B+
4.14 48 Hours - A+
4.15 Summit - A+
4.16 Last Stand - A+
4.17 Fail Safe - A
4.18 The Warrior - A+
4.19 Menace - B+
4.20 The Sentinel - B
4.21 Meridian - A+
4.22 Revelations - A+

Season Six:
6.01 Redemption, Pt 1 - A+
6.02 Redemption, Pt 2 - A+
6.03 Descent - A
6.04 Frozen - A+
6.05 Nightwalkers - B-
6.06 Abyss - A+
6.07 Shadow Play - B
6.08 The Other Guys - C-
6.09 Allegiance - A-
6.10 Cure - B+
6.11 Prometheus - A+
6.12 Unnatural Selection - A+
6.13 Sight Unseen - B
6.14 Smoke & Mirrors - A-
6.15 Paradise Lost - B-
6.16 Metamorphosis - B-
6.17 Disclosure - A-
6.18 Forsaken - B
6.19 The Changeling - A+
6.20 Memento - A
6.21 Prophecy - A
6.22 Full Circle - A+

Season Seven:
7.01 Fallen - A
7.02 Homecoming - A-
7.03 Fragile Balance - A
7.04 Orpheus - B+
7.05 Revisions - B
7.06 Lifeboat - B
7.07 Enemy Mine - C+
7.08 Space Race - B
7.09 Avenger 2.0 - D-
7.10 Birthright - B+
7.11 Evolution, Pt 1 - A-
7.12 Evolution, Pt 2 - B+
7.13 Grace - A+
7.14 Fallout - B
7.15 Chimera - C
7.16 Death Knell - A+
7.17 Heroes, Pt 1 - A+
7.18 Heroes, Pt 1 - A+
7.19 Resurrection - C-
7.20 Inauguration - B+
7.21 Lost City, Pt 1 - A+
7.22 Lost City, Pt 2 - A+

Season Eight:
8.01 New Order, Pt 1 - A
8.02 New Order, Pt 2 - A
8.03 Lockdown - B
8.04 Zero Hour - A-
8.05 Icon - A
8.06 Avatar - B+
8.07 Affinity - B+
8.08 Covenant - A-
8.09 Sacrifices - C+
8.10 Endgame - B+
8.11 Gemini - A-
8.12 Prometheus Unbound - A+
8.13 It's Good to Be King - A-
8.14 Full Alert - B+
8.15 Citizen Joe - C-
8.16 Reckoning, Pt 1 - A+
8.17 Reckoning, Pt 1 - A+
8.18 Threads - A+
8.19 Moebius, Pt 1 - A
8.20 Moebius, Pt 2 - A

Season Nine:
9.01 Avalon, Pt 1 - B+
9.02 Avalon, Pt 2 - A-
9.03 Origin - A-
9.04 The Ties That Bind - B
9.05 The Powers That Be - A
9.06 Beachhead - A+
9.07 Ex Deus Machina - B
9.08 Babylon - A-
9.09 Prototype - A
9.10 The Fourth Horseman, Pt 1 - A-
9.11 The Fourth Horseman, Pt 2 - A-
9.12 Collateral Damage - B
9.13 Ripple Effect - A+
9.14 Stronghold - B-
9.15 Ethon - A+
9.16 Off the Grid - B
9.17 The Scourge - A-
9.18 Arthur's Mantle - A-
9.19 Crusade - A-
9.20 Camelot - A-

Season Ten:
10.01 Flesh and Blood - A+
10.02 Morpheus - A-
10.03 The Pegasus Project - A+
10.04 Insiders - B-
10.05 Uninvited - B+
10.06 200 - A+
10.07 Counterstrike - A+
10.08 Memento Mori - A-
10.09 Company of Thieves - A
10.10 The Quest, Pt 1 - B+
10.11 The Quest, Pt 2 - A-
10.12 Line in the Sand - A+
10.13 The Road Not Taken - A+
10.14 The Shroud - A+
10.15 Bounty - B
10.16 Bad Guys - C+
10.17 Talion - A+
10.18 Family Ties - C
10.19 Dominion - A
10.20 Unending - A

Season 1: C+
Season 2: B+
Season 4: A
Season 5: A+
Season 6: A+
Season 7: A
Season 8: A
Season 9: A-
Season 10: A+
Ark of Truth: A-
Continuum: B+
Whole series: A++ = Awesomeness. That is all.

SGU

Spoiler: -

Season One:
1.01 Air, Pt 1 - B
1.02 Air, Pt 2 - A-
1.03 Air, Pt 3 - B+
1.04 Darkness - B-
1.05 Light - A+
1.06 Water - F
1.07 Earth - D-
1.08 Time - A+
1.09 Life - D+
1.10 Justice - B+
1.11 Space - A-
1.12 Divided - A
1.13 Faith - B+
1.14 Human - A-
1.15 Lost - A-
1.16 Sabotage - B
1.17 Pain - C-
1.18 Subversion - A+
1.19 Incursion, Pt 1 - A
1.20 Incursion, Pt 2 - A

Season Two:
2.01 Intervention - A
2.02 Aftermath - A+
2.03 Awakening - A
2.04 Pathogen - D+
2.05 Cloverdale - C+
2.06 Trial and Error - A
2.07 The Greater Good - A
2.08 Malice - A
2.09 Visitation - C+
2.10 Resurgence - B-
2.11 Deliverance - C
2.12 Twin Destinies - A+
2.13 Alliances - B-
2.14 Hope - B
2.15 Seizure - B+
2.16 The Hunt - B+
2.17 Common Descent - A
2.18 Epilogue - A
2.19 Blockade - A
2.20 Gauntlet - A+

Season 1: B+
Season 2: A
Entire series: A- = pretty damn good but nowhere near SG1 territory.

 

[Mr. A]

You guys really do have a lot of time. Not to mention an excellent memory!

 

[EvilSpaceAlien]

You guys really do have a lot of time. Not to mention an excellent memory!

Well to be honest I actually had to check the Stargate wiki a few times to remember what 4-8 SG1 episodes were about.

 

[heisenberg]

Pathetic..

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1286039/

7.9/10 over 6,000 votes
SGA
8.1 out of 8,000 votes